Hi Bob,
We recommend to check out the following options for Ambergris Caye:

Mata Rocks: Small, intimate, mediterranean, moderately priced
http://matarocks.com/

Banana Beach Resort: Older, moderately priced, nice, friendly and locally owned the last time we checked.
http://bananabeach.com/

Xanadu Island Resort
Quaint, surrounded by beautiful tropical gardens
http://xanaduislandresort.com/

Victoria House
http://www.victoria-house.com/accommodations/
Beautiful larger property, upscale and elegant, exclusive and higher priced

Banyan Bay Resort
http://www.banyanbay.com/
Also elegant and upscale, larger property, higher priced

Sunbreeze Hotel
Location right across from airport. Nothing fancy but good value for the price and nice beachfront. Not too small, not too big. There is also a Sunbreeze Suites in San Pedro, the town. The suites are also nice but no beach.
http://www.sunbreeze.net/

Those would be my recommendations.

Pia

Pia Hilbert
Caribbean Sky Tours